![]() |
|
Auto gate not working for me? - Printable Version +- XOR Userforum (https://forum.xor.eu) +-- Forum: Products (https://forum.xor.eu/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: NerdSEQ (https://forum.xor.eu/forumdisplay.php?fid=6) +---- Forum: General Questions (https://forum.xor.eu/forumdisplay.php?fid=17) +---- Thread: Auto gate not working for me? (/showthread.php?tid=280) Pages:
1
2
|
Auto gate not working for me? - xarnyz - 01-19-2019 Hi! Just got this awesome piece of hardware, put in 16 straight notes with nothing in the trigger column. It only fires my envelope once, and stays open. Plugged trigger into the scope, and see it staying open, but it has tiny dips at the regular intervals my notes are at. Do I need to calibrate or something? v1.17 Thanks for any help/advice you can give! ![]()
RE: Auto gate not working for me? - XORadmin - 01-19-2019 Hi there and thanks for the purchase. There is nothing wrong with your device. Thats the intended behaviour. Because: You have the Auto-Gating and then when it sees a note, it will set the gate. If the gate is set and it reaches another note, it will very shortly release the gate and set it again with the new note to automatically restart envelopes etc. It is very short and in practise not all envelopes (or macro oscillators!) can handle it. But there are multiple options to avoid the retriggering. At first, if you turn off the auto-gate function, then you got to take care when the gate should be set or not. ( By using the trigger column, FE sets the trigger/gate, 00 resets the trigger/gate.) Another option with the auto gating on is to use the Kill command with value 000 which doesn't change the current status of the gate. So if it was set at the moment it reaches the note (with the Kill000), then it stays set and if it wasn't set, then it stays off. Or when using the trigger commands in combination with the notes, then the trigger overrules the auto-gating behaviour of the notes. RE: Auto gate not working for me? - xarnyz - 01-19-2019 (01-19-2019, 08:29 AM)XORadmin Wrote: Hi there and thanks for the purchase. Oh I want the gate to retrigger. I would absolutely love for the auto gating to work for me. It's a wonderful feature that would make this behave like a tracker. I just cant find an envelope in my system that will respond to such a fast retrigger. The last thing I want is to avoid retriggering. I want boiBOIboiBOIboi not boiIIIiiiIIIiiiIIIiii Hopefully I don't have to program each and every retrigger and line up the bpm to the 10-F0 millisecond trigger length system to emulate an autogating function. Ok, if I put an F0 trigger on EVERY note in that pattern (you probably have it set to auto fill those in) it gives me something close to what I want. I would rather have auto-gating working like the manual says though. Try out some notes with NO values in the trig column, watch the auto-gate stay wide open the entire time rather than auto-gating. Your clock timing is rock solid! My ears have never been happier with how timing of a sequencer sounds (even modular ones) Now if only I could get my gates closer together without having to up my amp-envelope release to pretend like its working
RE: Auto gate not working for me? - XORadmin - 01-19-2019 I understand. But thats the way of modular synths in general, the difference to a tracker is that it restarts samples (or it sends a midi off before a new midi note) while with modular you got to trigger/retrigger envelopes and stuff to get to your results. For longer Auto-Gating pauses there is one issue you got to consider. The longer the Off time, the more your note is delayed and so it doesn't start exactly on the step but a bit later. Thats why i choosed a very short off time. So in fact, using the triggers is probably your best option. You can also turn on that the trigger is inserted automatically when inserting a note, that saves you manually inserting the trigger. And you might want to insert different trigger lengths anyway (or couple an automator to it) to make the boiBOIboiBOIboi more living, the BPM is not affected by the trigger lengths. BTW, Auto-Gating means that if a note is filled in, without any extras, that the gate is being set then. RE: Auto gate not working for me? - XORadmin - 01-19-2019 Maybe it's an option for you to add it to the feature requests where you can change the OFF time length when using auto-gate. I will consider everything there to add it, but also with priorities (and demand) and this doesn't sound like a high priority thing to me as you can reach your goal in multiple ways already. But if there is more demand for it... RE: Auto gate not working for me? - xarnyz - 01-19-2019 (01-19-2019, 09:40 AM)XORadmin Wrote: Maybe it's an option for you to add it to the feature requests where you can change the OFF time length when using auto-gate. I see why you'd use such a short rather non-existent gate now. To fix without affecting timing, you would need to read-ahead of the play position and see if a new note is incoming soon, and then gate off right before you get to the new note. That's probably a bit of an undertaking. And id rather not use autogates if it is implemented in the way you say. (it would delay timing of every note) Thanks for your help! This is a keeper. RE: Auto gate not working for me? - XORadmin - 01-19-2019 I am of course aware about to read-ahead the next step...which is impossible in many cases and would give wrong results. As an expample: - When using the break command with it's options. So read ahead must consider those including any probability. - End of pattern -> New Pattern is kind of critical to determine, as the pattern play must have information about the main sequencer play - Using Jump / Random Jump - for sure many more situations including probabilities, triggering behaviour of the future step etc.. - all the stuff that i still going to implement which will be in the way to determine well ... Trust me, it is of course possible, but this is more than a major work. The NerdSEQ is much more than a simple linear 16 step sequencer where you could do this. In general i think, given that a read-ahead is not possible easily, the flexibility of all linear and non-linear thing you CAN do pays this back 1000 times. And still, you can do everything you want to. Just see it as 2,5 different approaches: 1: While the Auto gate is usually being used to set a 'note on' here, a 'note off' there, another 'note on' here .... 2: And for envelope triggering and here more especially short triggers, the trigger column gives all flexibility. 2,5: And all in between to combine both. RE: Auto gate not working for me? - XORadmin - 01-19-2019 Haha, and i sound kind of negative. I'm not Always open for help and try to explain why things are made like they are....Which of course isn't always the best way. I'm continuosly improving stuff and alot from ideas i get from here.
RE: Auto gate not working for me? - xarnyz - 01-20-2019 (01-19-2019, 11:07 AM)XORadmin Wrote: Haha, and i sound kind of negative. I'm not You sound fine, haha. Now I'm wishing 10-F0 triggers worked on note lengths rather than milliseconds, when I use them, if I slow down a song's tempo, those gates don't slow down making them less useful for me on slower songs. F0 is still very much faster than a 1/16th note especially at slow tempos, and becomes a 16th note at around 200 bpm. You probably want it this way for some reason. RE: Auto gate not working for me? - XORadmin - 01-20-2019 You can fill in a note-off for that. |